Let’s play GM

Well the media for the most part has made Twins GM Bill Smith out to be the fool in the Johan Santana trade. In many ways it’s justified. He could have had Phil Hughes at one point (supposedly), and Hughes alone is probably better than what he got. But just for a minute, pretend you’re the GM of the Twins on Tuesday.

You have the best pitcher in baseball, but he won’t sign a long term deal. You have him for one more season at $13+ million. He comes to you and says “trade me now, or I’ll use my no trade rights and just stay for the season and bolt at the end.” So you’ve got to trade him or keep him. The Red Sox and Yankees have both pulled out, despite the fact that you offered the Yankees a deal without Phil Hughes (Ian Kennedy and Chien-Ming Wang, as it were). That leaves you with the Mets, who are offering 4 B-range prospects. One kid is a project pitcher with potential, 2 others are young pitchers with limited upside but a good shot to be members of the rotation. The last is a kid ready to play a great CF and steal bases at the Major League level but his bat may or may not pan out.

So you have two options: do you hold onto Santana or pull the trigger? Sure if you keep Santana, you’ll still get draft picks. And of course, you could have a draft like the Yankees in ’06 where you use those picks to choose Ian Kennedy and Joba Chamberlain (not literally, but players of the same caliber). But most top picks do not pan out and become real prospects, especially when you’re the Twins and you can’t draft anyone who demands a signing bonus. Those 4 guys the Mets are offering will likely all be better than the 2 guys you draft.

So again, what do you do? I think you have to make the trade. It sucks. But you have to. And what makes it worse, the average fan certainly does not understand the economics of it.


One response to “Let’s play GM

  1. I think you’re spot on. Let’s face it, yes, the Yankees had the best offer. But if that offer is off the table, and you’re left with nothing else but the Mets, that’s life.

    I think they definately saw more value on the trade market for Santana than was actually there. They expected to be able to get more from the Yankees and the Red Sox, and just didn’t get it in the end. Instead of two prospects, they get four, and they had a little bit more control of their options at letast.

    Still, I feel bad for Twins fans. I realize the team has found success in years past, but it does seem like they are always rebuilding some part of their team. It’s not easy being a small market team.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s